Rajasthan High Court Rules That Accused Can Be Asked To Provide Voice Sample For Future References

Must Read

Benefit of Probation Not Excluded by the Provisions of Mandatory Minimum Sentence Under Section 397 of Ipc

This case concerns the dispute regarding the granting of probation on good conduct to the accused under the age...

Supreme Court Asks for the Centre’s Response on PIL Filed Seeking the Formation of a Media Tribunal

The Supreme Court sought responses from the Press Council of India (PCI), News Broadcasters Association (NBA) on a PIL which sought to set up a media tribunal to tackle issues concerning the media like complaints against media, channels, and networks. Media has become like an unruly horse that has to be tamed to express the plea.

Law Student Asked the Supreme Court To Take Suo Moto Cognizance of the Violent Farmer Protests

A law student of Mumbai University, Ashish Rai has asked the Supreme Court to take Suo Moto Cognizance of the insult to the national flag done by the farmer protests at the Red Fort. In the course of the farmer's tractor rally on Tuesday, some of the protesters unfurled their own flags by entering the premises of the Red Fort.

Farmers Meeting With the Supreme Court Committee Postponed To Jan 29 Due To the Traffic Restrictions

Due to the traffic restrictions after the violent protests broke out on Republic Day, the meeting of farmers with the Supreme Court Committee that was supposed to take place today was postponed to 29th January.

Supreme Court Stays Bombay HC Judgment which said Groping without Skin Contact Not Sexual Assault under POCSO

The National Commission for Women (NCW) has challenged the Bombay High Court judgment where it stated that groping a child’s breasts without any ‘skin-to-skin’ contact will not be considered as sexual assault as defined under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act.

Supreme Court Classifying Employees Based on Educational Qualifications for Promotion or Appointment Is Neither Violative of Article 14 nor of Article 16

This case concerns the dispute relating to the classification of employees belonging to the homogenous group based on educational...

Follow us

Rajasthan High Court’s recent ruling gave a major boost to law enforcement agencies. The Court allowed police to collect voice samples of an accused person for determining his or her involvement in the crime.

Facts Of The Case

Events of this case take place in Jodhpur where some armed youth in the wee hours of morning indiscriminately fired gunshots at the residents of two persons namely Dr. Sunil Chandak and Mr. Manish Jain. A CCTV footage of the incident revealed that some youth on a motorcycle stopped in front of houses of Dr. Chandak and Mr. Jain and started indiscriminate firing. Thereafter both the victims were threatened on their mobile phones, whereby the person calling them reminded of the firing on their house in the morning and asked them for protection money for the safety of their family members and themselves.

On investigation, it was revealed that calls came from Italy through Voice Over Internet Protocol (VOIP). Accused was arrested from Indira Gandhi International Airport at New Delhi when he was trying to flee the country and he has confessed making those threatening calls on directions of one Lawrence Bishnoi who is in jail. Police presented an application before Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate No.2 Jodhpur seeking permission of the court to direct the accused to give voice sample for matching his voice with recording provided by Dr. Chandak. Accused refused to give his consent for the same. Learned Magistrate dismissed the application filed by police saying that in absence of any express provision of law which empowers police to take voice sample, it is not permissible for police to ask accused to give his voice spectrography test. Police filed a revision petition in Additional Session’s Judge against this decision of Magistrate. The decision of Magistrate was upheld by Additional Session’s Judge and revision petition under section 482 was filed in the High Court.

Decision Of The Case

Learned Single Judge Justice Vijay Bishnoi after listening to both the sides came to the conclusion that the revision petition is maintainable under section 482 of the Cr.P.C and High Court can decide the matter even if the issue is pending before the larger bench in Supreme Court. Furthermore, keeping in mind the facts of the case the Court also opined that “The members of the gang made calls through Whatsapp or VOIP or other techniques from within country or from foreign country knowing well that it is very difficult to prove that they have called the victim because they cannot be compelled to give their voice sample. Misuse of technology can only be countered by good use of technology. Moreover, the court also opined that “it is not justified to restrain police or investigating agency to counter crime with aid of scientific methods or modern technology on the ground that there is no provision of this effect under any law.” Last but not the least, the court also issued directions guiding police as to how they should take and use the voice sample.

Learning of the case

From this case, we learn several things. First, a revision petition is maintainable before the high court under section 482 even after rejection by session’s judge and secondly police can now take help of scientific methods and latest technology in investigating the matter.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest News

Benefit of Probation Not Excluded by the Provisions of Mandatory Minimum Sentence Under Section 397 of Ipc

This case concerns the dispute regarding the granting of probation on good conduct to the accused under the age of twenty-one years.   Brief facts of...

Supreme Court Asks for the Centre’s Response on PIL Filed Seeking the Formation of a Media Tribunal

The Supreme Court sought responses from the Press Council of India (PCI), News Broadcasters Association (NBA) on a PIL which sought to set up a media tribunal to tackle issues concerning the media like complaints against media, channels, and networks. Media has become like an unruly horse that has to be tamed to express the plea.

Law Student Asked the Supreme Court To Take Suo Moto Cognizance of the Violent Farmer Protests

A law student of Mumbai University, Ashish Rai has asked the Supreme Court to take Suo Moto Cognizance of the insult to the national flag done by the farmer protests at the Red Fort. In the course of the farmer's tractor rally on Tuesday, some of the protesters unfurled their own flags by entering the premises of the Red Fort.

Farmers Meeting With the Supreme Court Committee Postponed To Jan 29 Due To the Traffic Restrictions

Due to the traffic restrictions after the violent protests broke out on Republic Day, the meeting of farmers with the Supreme Court Committee that was supposed to take place today was postponed to 29th January.

Supreme Court Stays Bombay HC Judgment which said Groping without Skin Contact Not Sexual Assault under POCSO

The National Commission for Women (NCW) has challenged the Bombay High Court judgment where it stated that groping a child’s breasts without any ‘skin-to-skin’ contact will not be considered as sexual assault as defined under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act.

Supreme Court Classifying Employees Based on Educational Qualifications for Promotion or Appointment Is Neither Violative of Article 14 nor of Article 16

This case concerns the dispute relating to the classification of employees belonging to the homogenous group based on educational qualifications. Brief facts of the case The...

Supreme Court Refuses To Transfer Petitions To Itself Related To ‘Love Jihad’ Filed in Allahabad High Court

On Monday, the Supreme Court refused to entertain the plea which was filed by the UP Government regarding the transfer of all the pleas challenging the ordinance the court passed, from Allahabad High Court to the Supreme Court.

Bombay HC Nagpur Bench Holds That Groping a Girl Without ‘Skin To Skin’ Contact Is Not Sexual Assault

The Nagpur bench of Bombay High Court acquitted a man charged under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) and convicted him of a minor offence under IPC stating that there was no direct physical contact.

Delhi High Court Restrains Publication of Book on “the Ryan School Murder”

The Order had come in an injunction application filed by the St. Xavier's Education Trust in Delhi. The Plaintiff sought ad-interim restraining order on...

Supreme Court Closed Proceeding in Case of “in Re: Advocate on Record Includes a Proprietary Firm Etc.”

Brief facts of the case Emails from the Petitioner resulted in an administrative decision. An Order of the Supreme Court has drawn up the issue...

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -