Accused Cannot Be Discharged Without Appreciation of Evidence Rules Supreme Court

Must Read

SC: Under-21 Convicts Can Be Given Less Than Minimum Sentence, Resorts To Probation of Offenders Act

The Supreme Court resorted to the Probation of Offenders Act to sidestep the mandate under Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code that mentions a sentence of not less than 7 years to those convicted of armed robbery, to give a chance to two young convicts to reform their lives.

Environment Protection Act Passed at the Instance of Foreign Powers: NHAI in Karnataka HC

The National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) claimed in a submission that the Environment Protection Act 1986 was passed not only for the protection of the environment by the parliament but also at the instance of foreign powers. This statement was made while referring to a UN conference and got the NHAI into great trouble in the Karnataka High Court.

Delhi High Court To Implement a Hybrid System Through Virtual and Physical Hearing

On Friday the Delhi High Court said that they have initiated steps to implement a mode wherein hearing can be done by virtual as well as physical mode. The Delhi High Court is aiming to implement the Hybrid mode. It stated that when the particular bench is conducting a virtual hearing the lawyer may opt for this mode after giving prior intimation about the same.

Mercy Plea of Rajiv Gandhi Assassination Case To Be Decided in Four Weeks, TN Governor To Supreme Court

Tamil Nadu Governor Banwarilal Purohit on Thursday told the Supreme Court that a decision on the mercy petition of one of the convicts serving a life sentence for the assassination of former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi, AG Perarivalan will be taken within four weeks. The petition has been pending with the Governor since December 30, 2015.

Bombay High Court Questions FIR Over Journalist Alleged of Communist Comment on WhatsApp

An FIR lodged against the editor of Marathi newspaper, Rajkumar Chhajed has been questioned by the Bombay High Court. The Maharashtra Police has accused Chhajed of creating a rift between the two communities based on a WhatsApp message.

Allahabad High Court Expresses Dissatisfaction on Counsels Seeking Unnecessary Adjournments

The petition had been filed by Smt. Radha prayed to issue directions to Judicial Magistrate-I in Faizabad. The petition...

Follow us

Supreme Court of India set aside Bombay High Court order discharging the accused in the Loharia murder case, thereby reviving prosecution against Navi Mumbai builder Sumeet Bachewar.

Facts of the Case

Accused were charged for murder by the police under section 302 of the Indian Penal Code on the basis of statements recorded by it under section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1908. Two sets of evidence were available with the prosecution. First was a statement given by the deceased to an auto-rickshaw driver and employee of deceased while being taken to the hospital for treatment. Accused mentioned the name of Suresh Bijlani and Anurag Shivmohan Garg. The second set of evidence is a statement given by the deceased to his son who is also the appellant in the present matter. According to the appellant he had arrived at the Hospital at about 8:40 am and the deceased stated before him that he was attacked and injured, apart from Suresh Bijlani and Anurag Garg three other person namely Sumeet Bachewar, S.P Agarwal, and Bhupesh Prakashchand Gupta were also involved in the attack. Trial Court refused to the discharge plea of the accused against which a revision petition was preferred in the High Court of Bombay. High Court of Bombay overturned the decision of Trial Court in the revision petition. Bombay High Court ordered the discharge of the accused after observing that statement made by the appellant appears to be calculated and does not indicate trustworthiness in comparison to statements made by persons who accompanied the deceased to hospital. Appellant feeling wronged by the decision preferred a special leave petition against the order of Bombay High Court.

Senior Counsel Mrs Indira Jai Singh appearing for respondents relying on a judgment of Supreme Court namely Yogesh alias Sachin Jagdish Joshi v. the State of Maharashtra contended that the broad test for discharging the accused is that if material on record, if unrebutted, makes a conviction reasonably possible.

Verdict

The Full Bench of Justice Ranjan Gogoi, Justice Navin Sinha, Justice K.M Joseph after listening to both the sides felt that decision of discharging the accused taken by Bombay High Court was ‘premature’ and accordingly set aside the impugned order. The Full Bench rejected the contention of Senior Lawyer Indira Jai Singh said that since the evidence is analyzed weighed and appreciated without checking the authenticity of the two versions in cross-examination it cannot be said that there are two possible views of the matter. Therefore, the observation of this Court in Yogesh alias Sachin Jagdish Joshi will, therefore not assist the accused. Furthermore, the Court said that

“Appreciation of evidence is an exercise that High Court, in our considered view, could not have undertaken at this stage of consideration of the application for discharge. But this is what precisely what High Court appears to have been done.” Last but not the least, Court made it clear that their interference with High Court order will is in no way expression of opinion on the merits of rival contentions which will naturally have to be considered at the trail.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest News

SC: Under-21 Convicts Can Be Given Less Than Minimum Sentence, Resorts To Probation of Offenders Act

The Supreme Court resorted to the Probation of Offenders Act to sidestep the mandate under Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code that mentions a sentence of not less than 7 years to those convicted of armed robbery, to give a chance to two young convicts to reform their lives.

Environment Protection Act Passed at the Instance of Foreign Powers: NHAI in Karnataka HC

The National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) claimed in a submission that the Environment Protection Act 1986 was passed not only for the protection of the environment by the parliament but also at the instance of foreign powers. This statement was made while referring to a UN conference and got the NHAI into great trouble in the Karnataka High Court.

Delhi High Court To Implement a Hybrid System Through Virtual and Physical Hearing

On Friday the Delhi High Court said that they have initiated steps to implement a mode wherein hearing can be done by virtual as well as physical mode. The Delhi High Court is aiming to implement the Hybrid mode. It stated that when the particular bench is conducting a virtual hearing the lawyer may opt for this mode after giving prior intimation about the same.

Mercy Plea of Rajiv Gandhi Assassination Case To Be Decided in Four Weeks, TN Governor To Supreme Court

Tamil Nadu Governor Banwarilal Purohit on Thursday told the Supreme Court that a decision on the mercy petition of one of the convicts serving a life sentence for the assassination of former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi, AG Perarivalan will be taken within four weeks. The petition has been pending with the Governor since December 30, 2015.

Bombay High Court Questions FIR Over Journalist Alleged of Communist Comment on WhatsApp

An FIR lodged against the editor of Marathi newspaper, Rajkumar Chhajed has been questioned by the Bombay High Court. The Maharashtra Police has accused Chhajed of creating a rift between the two communities based on a WhatsApp message.

Allahabad High Court Expresses Dissatisfaction on Counsels Seeking Unnecessary Adjournments

The petition had been filed by Smt. Radha prayed to issue directions to Judicial Magistrate-I in Faizabad. The petition sought a speedy decision in...

[Delhi Riots] When the IT Ministry Calls Us, We Will Go Says Harish Salve To Delhi High Court

The Vice President and Managing Director of Facebook, Ajit Mohan told the Supreme Court that when the representatives of the company are called by the Information Technology Ministry they will come and record their statements.

Allahabad High Court Seeks Response on Compensation of Cutting Trees From National Highways Authority of India (Nhai) 

The Order had come in the form of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by a bunch of law students in Uttar Pradesh. The...

Doctrine of Proportionality Must Adhere to Reasonableness Principal Test: Madras High Court

Young Men's Christian Association built a commercial complex and leased it without having due permission. The District Collector & Tahsildar issued a show-cause notice...

Delhi High Court Refuses To Stay Release of ‘The White Tiger’ on the OTT Platform Netflix

A plea requesting a stay on the release of the film ‘The White Tiger’ by the American producer, John Hart Jr. alleging copyright violation was rejected by the Delhi High Court on Thursday.

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -