Branding a Cause: TM Application For ‘Black Lives Matter’ And ‘I Can Breathe’ Falls Flat

Must Read

Explained: The Right to be Forgotten in India

Right to Privacy is an essential fundamental right which has been enshrined in the Indian Constitution under Article 21...

How will the New WhatsApp Privacy Policy Affect Us?

On January 4, 2020, the California based tech giant WhatsApp announced its new privacy law. It allows data integration...

India’s International ‘Retrospective Taxation’ Regime Vis-a-Vis PCA Rulings in Vodafone and Cairn in 2020

The imposition of retrospective taxation of foreign companies doing business in India has been at the helm of controversy...

What is the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016?

The Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (“RERA”) is an Act of the Parliament. It seeks to protect...

Should the Exorbitant Amounts Charged for RT-PCR Tests be Refunded?

Introduction A plea has been filed in the Honourable Supreme Court of India seeking a refund of exorbitant amounts charged...

Should CCTV’s be Installed in the Police Station?

Introduction In a recent judgment, the bench led by Justice Nariman issued directions to both the state and Union Territory...

Follow us

From India’s ‘Simon Go Back’ to Suffragettes’ ‘Votes for Women’ to America’s anti war ‘Not in My Name’, slogans have always held the power to unite. The rallying cry ‘Black Lives Matter’ (BLM) has gained new momentum amidst the protest against systematic racism in American policing. Thousands of people across the globe have taken to the streets to protest the murder of George Floyd by the hands of the police.

In other news, trademark (TM) applications for the terms “BLACK LIVES MATTER” and “I CAN’T BREATHE” have surged. The applicants have faced backlash over the blatant abuse of opportunity and intention to profit off tragedy. 

History of Black Lives Matter (BLM)

In 2013, Alicia Garza, Patrice Cullors and Opal Tomett, were discussing the acquittal of a man who killed Trayvon Martin. Martin was a 17-year old black teenager in Florida. “Our Lives Matter, Black Lives Matter,” Ms. Garza wrote on Facebook. Ms. Cullors replied, “#BlackLivesMatter”. Ms. Tometi joined in and the hashtag spread its digital wings.

From then on, the murder of innocents like Michael Brown, Sandra Bland, Tamir Rice and many more have turned #BlackLivesMatter from a hashtag to a movement. BLM is now an organized movement with a foundation in its name working globally. The organization sells official merchandise, proceeds from which goes to fund the movement. The founders chose not to trademark these powerful phrases that would restrict public use. 

‘I can’t breathe’ became a rallying cry after Eric Garner’s murder in the hands of the police on camera went viral. Like George Floyd, Garner’s last words were ‘I can’t breathe’.

Facts of the Case 

Manchester-based businessperson Georgios Demetriou filed trademark applications “I CAN’T BREATHE” (Application no. 3497640) and “BLACK LIVES MATTER” (Application no. 3497647). He is the founder of bicycle selling business Licence to Thrill Ltd.

In an interview, he claimed that he had submitted the applications to raise money for charity. The proceeds from the charity would go to ‘help people from Manchester and beyond’. He hopes to build relations with ‘big name’ companies who would pay him ‘royalty’ for using the terms. Ironically, Dimitri also said that these trademarks would belong to the people and not to him. 

Public backlash and response of UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO)

Social media had exploded when news of the TM applications broke out. Twitteraties were quick to point out Demetriou’s abject apathy towards the cause. UK TM expert Erik Pelton said attempting to secure exclusive rights to use these phrases is reprehensible and likely to fail. Demetriou claims that he had gotten threat calls, along with his employees.

UKIPO in an unprecedented move responded via a tweet on twitter. It stated that decisions of the IPO are important for both the applicant and the public. They have a responsibility to examine the validity of all applications like these under trademark law. Their decision will not be without recognition of current and historical injustices. It further invited ‘observations’ by the public if the registration process reaches that stage. Ultimately, Demetriou withdrew the TM application citing fear from threat.

Analysis

Since the death of George Floyd, there have been at least 26 TM applications of these terms in USA. In general, efforts to trademark political slogans or campaign slogans are not new. Trayvon Martin’s mother herself moved to trademark ‘I am Trayvon’ and ‘justice for Trayvon’ after he was brutally killed by the police in 2012.

In 2017 Hard Candy, a cosmetic company moved to trademark #metoo after it gained momentum on social media. While Hard Candy withdrew the application facing public backlash, Trayvon’s mark is registered. Trademarks are marks that identify the source of goods and services. Its primary purpose is for consumers avoid to confusion.

Nearly anything can be subject of trademark including color, smell etc. as long as it serves the purpose of identifying source of product. Political slogans can be trademarked as Donald J. Trump successfully registered the phrase ‘Make America Great Again’ in 2015. Trump has used ‘MAGA’ as a brand strategy, selling himself with the slogan during the Presidential run of 2016.

On the other hand, slogans such ‘BLM’, ‘I can’t breathe’, ‘Boston Strong’ etc have become universal and cannot be attributed to one ‘proprietor’. Even the people who have coined the terms/phrases do not own them. Previously, while rejecting these types of applications USPTO said these marks used in rallies, are dedicated to raising awareness of civil rights, protesting violence and conveying the message of support for the same. According to IP expert Lee Curtis, registering these trademarks is contrary to public policy or to accepted principles of morality. 

Conclusion

There is an economic undertone to trademark. It restricts others from using the mark without the permission of the proprietor. These events prove that opportunistic trademark applications can face extreme backlash. However, as UKIPO rightly said the registry has to consider each application individually keeping in mind its impact on the greater community.


Libertatem.in is now on Telegram. Follow us for regular legal updates and judgements from the court. Follow us on Google News, InstagramLinkedInFacebook & Twitter. You can also subscribe for our Weekly Email Updates. You can also contribute stories like this and help us spread awareness for a better society. Submit Your Post Now.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest News

Benefit of Probation Not Excluded by the Provisions of Mandatory Minimum Sentence Under Section 397 of Ipc

This case concerns the dispute regarding the granting of probation on good conduct to the accused under the age of twenty-one years.   Brief facts of...

Supreme Court Asks for the Centre’s Response on PIL Filed Seeking the Formation of a Media Tribunal

The Supreme Court sought responses from the Press Council of India (PCI), News Broadcasters Association (NBA) on a PIL which sought to set up a media tribunal to tackle issues concerning the media like complaints against media, channels, and networks. Media has become like an unruly horse that has to be tamed to express the plea.

Law Student Asked the Supreme Court To Take Suo Moto Cognizance of the Violent Farmer Protests

A law student of Mumbai University, Ashish Rai has asked the Supreme Court to take Suo Moto Cognizance of the insult to the national flag done by the farmer protests at the Red Fort. In the course of the farmer's tractor rally on Tuesday, some of the protesters unfurled their own flags by entering the premises of the Red Fort.

Farmers Meeting With the Supreme Court Committee Postponed To Jan 29 Due To the Traffic Restrictions

Due to the traffic restrictions after the violent protests broke out on Republic Day, the meeting of farmers with the Supreme Court Committee that was supposed to take place today was postponed to 29th January.

Supreme Court Stays Bombay HC Judgment which said Groping without Skin Contact Not Sexual Assault under POCSO

The National Commission for Women (NCW) has challenged the Bombay High Court judgment where it stated that groping a child’s breasts without any ‘skin-to-skin’ contact will not be considered as sexual assault as defined under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act.

Supreme Court Classifying Employees Based on Educational Qualifications for Promotion or Appointment Is Neither Violative of Article 14 nor of Article 16

This case concerns the dispute relating to the classification of employees belonging to the homogenous group based on educational qualifications. Brief facts of the case The...

Supreme Court Refuses To Transfer Petitions To Itself Related To ‘Love Jihad’ Filed in Allahabad High Court

On Monday, the Supreme Court refused to entertain the plea which was filed by the UP Government regarding the transfer of all the pleas challenging the ordinance the court passed, from Allahabad High Court to the Supreme Court.

Bombay HC Nagpur Bench Holds That Groping a Girl Without ‘Skin To Skin’ Contact Is Not Sexual Assault

The Nagpur bench of Bombay High Court acquitted a man charged under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) and convicted him of a minor offence under IPC stating that there was no direct physical contact.

Delhi High Court Restrains Publication of Book on “the Ryan School Murder”

The Order had come in an injunction application filed by the St. Xavier's Education Trust in Delhi. The Plaintiff sought ad-interim restraining order on...

Supreme Court Closed Proceeding in Case of “in Re: Advocate on Record Includes a Proprietary Firm Etc.”

Brief facts of the case Emails from the Petitioner resulted in an administrative decision. An Order of the Supreme Court has drawn up the issue...

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -