Field Occupied by Statutory Rules Cannot be Governed by Executive Instructions: Tripura High Court

Must Read

Madhya Pradesh High Court Asks State To File Reply To Examine Whether Privacy Rights of an Individual Can Be Violated by Issuing an Executive...

A Writ Petition was instituted by an individual for violation of his fundamental rights by the State before the...

Bombay High Court Allows Export of Pending Consignment of Onions in Respect of Which Shipping Bills Have Been Generated Before Notification of the Ban

A writ petition challenging the notification dated 14th September 2020 to ban the export of onions was filed by...

Delhi HC: Mens Rea Essential Before Passing an Order U/S 14b of EPF Act

  In the matter of M/s Durable Doors and Windows v APFC, Gurugram, the bench allowed the Petitioner's appeal holding...

Delhi HC: Language of Statement and Testimony of Complainant Need Not Be Identical

A single-judge bench of J. Vibhu Bakhru of the Delhi High Court upheld the accused's conviction in Kailash @...

COVID Results Shall Be Conveyed To the Person Within 24 Hours: Delhi High Court

The order has come in a writ petition moved by Rakesh Malhotra. The Petitioner herein seeks to ramp up...

Delhi High Court Sets Aside the Order of the Trial Court in the Chief Secretary Assault Case

In the case of Mr. Arvind Kejriwal & Anr. V. State NCT of Delhi, Mr.Justice Suresh Kumar Kait has...

Follow us

In Sri Abhishek Majumder vs Tripura Gramin Bank & Anr, Chief Justice Mr Akil Kureshi dealt with a petition that sought to set aside a distinction made between general and specialist cadre exclusively through executive instruction for the purpose of promotion. 

Facts of the Case

Petitioner joined as a clerk in the Respondent Bank after being selected through a competitive examination in 2011, a year later he was selected as a direct recruit to the post of Computer Engineer, further in 2014 as Officer Middle Management (Scale II). In 2019, promotion to Scale III was announced, with 4 vacancies, 2 each for normal channel and fast track promotion. For fast track channel, eligibility was 5 yrs experience in Scale II to which Petitioner applied. However the application was not considered and the reason cited was that the applicant was selected to Scale-II as a specialist cadre, distinct from the general stream. Such rejection has been challenged by the Petitioner.

Arguments Advanced

Petitioners contend that there is no demarcation between general and specialist cadre as per recruitment rules which mentioned the eligibility criteria which is 5 yrs experience. Such distinction has been made artificially without statutory backing and therefore such executive instructions run counter to rules.

Respondents contend that the Petitioner was appointed as specialist cadre due to knowledge in information technology; the Bank does not have a sanctioned post in specialist cadre under Scale-III. Respondents have relied on NABARD communication which stated that a specialist officer can’t be promoted in general category vacancy. The Petitioner was recruited while the recruitment rules of 2010 were applicable and which made a clear distinction between specialist and a general cadre.

Court’s Observation and Decision

The Regional Rural Banks Act was enacted to provide for incorporation, regulation and winding up of Regional Rural Banks with a view to developing the rural economy. Section 17 provides that a Regional Rural Bank may appoint such a number of officers and other employees, as it may consider necessary or desirable, for the efficient performance of its functions and may determine the terms and conditions of their appointment and service. Sub-section (1) of Section 29 provides that the Central Government may, after consultation with the National Bank and the Sponsor Bank, by notification in Official Gazette make rules for carrying out the provisions of the Act. In exercise of powers conferred under Section 29 read with Section 17 of the said Act, the Central Government framed the “Recruitment Rules of 2017”. Sl. No.2 in the Third Schedule of the Recruitment Rules of 2017 pertains to Officer Middle Management (Scale-II). Out of the vacancies for direct recruitment, 10% would be filled up from Specialist cadre such as Information Technology. Sl. No.3 in the Third Schedule of Recruitment Rules of 2017 pertains to Officer Middle Management (Scale-III). Promotion to the post under fast track process has been elucidated as having 5 yrs experience in Scale II on full time and regular basis. 

With respect to whether Candidates who were recruited under the Specialist cadre be kept out, the Court observed that the 2017 Rules were framed with the exercise of statutory basis and hence has statutory force. These rules make no distinction and therefore it cannot be made through executive instructions. If there are gaps in recruitment rules, it may be filled by executive instruction, however, executive instructions cannot run counter to rules. Consequently, the communication of rejection by Respondent was set aside and the application by Petitioner is liable to be considered for the selection process.

Click here to read the judgment.


Libertatem.in is now on Telegram. Follow us for regular legal updates and judgment from courts. Follow us on Google News, InstagramLinkedInFacebook & Twitter. You can subscribe to our Weekly Email Updates. You can also contribute stories like this and help us spread awareness for a better society. Submit Your Post Now.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest News

Madhya Pradesh High Court Asks State To File Reply To Examine Whether Privacy Rights of an Individual Can Be Violated by Issuing an Executive...

A Writ Petition was instituted by an individual for violation of his fundamental rights by the State before the Madhya Pradesh High Court. The...

Bombay High Court Allows Export of Pending Consignment of Onions in Respect of Which Shipping Bills Have Been Generated Before Notification of the Ban

A writ petition challenging the notification dated 14th September 2020 to ban the export of onions was filed by the Exporters Association before the...

Delhi HC: Mens Rea Essential Before Passing an Order U/S 14b of EPF Act

  In the matter of M/s Durable Doors and Windows v APFC, Gurugram, the bench allowed the Petitioner's appeal holding that mens rea is an...

Delhi HC: Language of Statement and Testimony of Complainant Need Not Be Identical

A single-judge bench of J. Vibhu Bakhru of the Delhi High Court upheld the accused's conviction in Kailash @ Balli v State. The bench...

COVID Results Shall Be Conveyed To the Person Within 24 Hours: Delhi High Court

The order has come in a writ petition moved by Rakesh Malhotra. The Petitioner herein seeks to ramp up testing facilities in Delhi.   Facts of...

Delhi High Court Sets Aside the Order of the Trial Court in the Chief Secretary Assault Case

In the case of Mr. Arvind Kejriwal & Anr. V. State NCT of Delhi, Mr.Justice Suresh Kumar Kait has set aside the 24.07.2019 Order...

Delhi High Court Temporarily Restrains Vintage Moments’ Alcohol Sale in Case of Trademark Infringement

The manufacturers of the Alcohol Brand Magic Moments had filed a suit. The Delhi High Court has passed an order restraining the manufacturing, marketing,...

NGT Red-Flags Kaleshwaram Project: Green Clearance Violated the Law, Halt Work

Excerpt The National Green Tribunal (NGT), Principal Bench, dated 20th October 2020, directed the Telangana government to stop all work, except the drinking water component...

There Can Be No Leniency Shown To Appellant Who Pleaded To Reduce Sentence: Delhi High Court

Facts On 25.2.2016 the victim’s sister who was 13 years old was present with her sister who was 2 years old (victim) at their home....

Violation of Executive Instructions Cannot Be Sole Ground to Invalidate Transfer Orders: Tripura High Court

In Dr Bithika Choudhury vs the State of Tripura & Ors., a Division Bench consisting of Hon’ble Justice S. Talapatra and Hon’ble Justice S.G. Chattopadhyay...

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -